Since submission I have gone back to my animation and tried to improve the animation to bring my characters to life even more, I've also been working on lighting in addition to 3D printing my characters. Here's scene 1 revisited - I was trying to make them move at all times to feel more alive and make them less mechanical/choppy movements. Below is a render from each shot.
Since my last post I have now animated the abuse montage, modelled the kitchen set (when I texture it I will post renders and apply post VFX), I've also received the first two minutes of my soundtrack from my composer and put in a few more sounds. I still need to put in some unsettling sounds to contrast the uplifting countryside ambience/tweeting birds heard when Fred is rescued by his family. The shot that transitions Fred from the church to the kitchen (Act 1 into Act 2) obviously needs more work but for now here's what I've got! Like the last post I've put in bits of my pre viz to fill the gaps of what's left to animate which is just Doris's search and finding Fred. I plan to have all scenes animated by Friday. UPDATE (10/05): The audio in Act 2 where lines seem to layer over each other this wasn’t meant to happen, I was up very late and got muddled up with my nest groups in premiere.
I haven't posted in a while so I thought I'd put together what I have of my post viz (with sound) so far with my pre viz filling in the gaps of shots I have yet to roughly/block animate. Note: I've just noticed a couple glitches in the first act so I will be fixing that when I get home tonight (03/05).
The letter box scene isn't 100% done yet, I still need to put in a camera shot showing the letter in Doris's hand, a close up of Doris's face before the shot below where we see her put the letter in - I have to make a rig to actually exchange the location of the letter within the scene from hand to letter box. The animation itself is a bit off with time and a bit floaty but this is something I'll have to come back too.
The shot below of Doris peering is more blocked than refined animation - it still needs work but again this is something I'll come back too.
Here is a chunk of Act 3 put together, before this chunk is the letter box scene (mostly done) and before that the reunion/milk bottle scene. The first shot in this video that has Doris needs to be reanimated as I accidentally deleted the head/face controls before I finished and saved over when I had it last before I realised they were gone...
Today I have been working on Scene 2 of Act 3, the reason for not diving straight into Act 2 is because I haven't modelled the interior of the house yet, I have the characters ready just not the set so until then I decided to crack on with Act 3. The first scene of Act 3 is the letter box scene which I have started and been working more on but it's proving to be more difficult than expected so I've moved on to the next shot and will return to that scene on a better day, (plus I was excited to start animating Rosa). I'm quite happy with how well I've kept to the reference, it may be a little bit of film but I feel it's a big step for me especially compared to my early animation posts for this project with their references.
"Is this the place?"
Note: I may be a couple frames off when putting the below video together.
Since my last post viz post I've got a couple more shots animated, a couple shots rendered and composited, a couple more voice actors in there and thanks to Phil I've discovered a lovely effect in premiere called 'vignette' a subtle effect around the edges of my film that contribute to the vintage/olden timey look I'm going for. I've only rendered a couple scenes, the first shot I did this because I want it on my demo reel and the last shot I did it for compositing the shadow. I'm aware the animation isn't the best it can be and some shots are better animated than others, but for now I'm leaving Act 1 and taking the lessons learned into Acts 2 and 3 otherwise I'll never get this film made. If by some miracle I have time at the end I will return to Act 1 and bring it up to the same standards as Acts 2 and 3 (because they should be better). Below the video are some notes I've made for myself when I return to Act 1.
Notes: Scene 1, Shot 2, (Fred CU on train): Fred's rigid he needs to be animated even though he is still. Also there's something odd about this shot that stands out to me in comparison to the ones before and after, maybe it's too close to his face? Do a playblast with the camera not so close and play with scale in premiere. Scene 1, Shot 3, (Doris CU pull out and train wipe): Doris is also quite rigid in this part I need to animate her a bit more. Scene 2, Shot 6, (Down shot on Fred and Doris): Need to animate more overlapping actions on Fred's looking down and Doris's nodding - it's rigid. Scene 2: Shot 7, (Fred grabs suitcase): He pulls away too quick. Scene 2: Shot 8, (He can't come with us): Need to animate the centre of gravity and spine more. Scene 2: Shot 9, (Downward roll shot of Fred): It's jittery - something to do with premiere probably. Scene 2: Shot 10, (Fred looks up and shadow appears): Lower scale on sub surface - looks a bit like a static tv under the skin a bit when batch rendered.
Today I've been cleaning up the animation for the very last shot of Act 1 and figuring out how to do the shadows with Alan's help, which is basically just a animated plane and a spotlight. The shadow is rendered out as a separate pass and composited, the reason you can't do this all at once is because a shadow is the blocking of light but as you can see in the screen capture below I have lights around Fred which cancel out that shadow.
Composited + Desaturation
Composited Only
Render before composite rendered at: 2:36
Scene Set Up
For this shot I couldn't decide if the second arm action felt right or not so I did a playblast with and without. I don't know which one to go with.
Today I have been working on the ending of Act 1, here's what I have roughed out for me to come back too at the end, (there was another shot I did that was in my pre viz but it didn't work so I've cut it). Also I've cut out a line from the script ("We haven't got all day") because I felt like it was unnecessary to add/keep, when I come back to this shot I may put it back in or change the animation to work with it. The first bit, the shots will be changed to include a better shot of their heart broken faces. What I'm trying to tell is Doris has to go, they both hadn't realised that Fred can't go with her, Doris being the older protective sister doesn't want to leave him but Fred decides to hide his upset and let her go. </3
I feel like I'm doing spoilers by posting this but, alas it's got to be done. Here is what I have of my film so far with sounds + a bit of voice acting. I've begun animating the next shot also, pictures below.
Below are screenshots of my 3 beats for the next bit, so after "Where do you think you're going?"
Doris and Fred initially react to this by looking at each other confused - What does that mean? I thought we had to stay together?"Well he can't come with us, darlin'."
Doris and Fred then respond, Fred looks to the ground not knowing what to do, Doris looks at Fred's response and uses this beat to decide what action she's going to take next. Her thoughts at this point would be, her parents told her to look after Fred so she's not gonna leave his side easily but she was also told to behave herself and do what people said.
Doris takes a defensive stance by stepping in front of Fred - where he goes, I go. "C'mon, don't be like that." Before reluctantly leaving him in the next part after.
I have given it a go at cleaning up and refining the animation for the very first scene of my film. Improvements made: the way Doris turns, Fred's eye darts so it looks like he is looking out the window at passing objects, their rocking with the train I've tried to make better, I've put in/tweaked slow ins and slow outs in the graph editor for both characters to make it look like the characters are flowing through poses rather than locking which was what was making it look mechanical before... In comparison to my last post for this shot, I think it has improved??? ... I hope it has.
I'm not sure if I've gone from mechanical to a bit floaty, still some work to be done. I'm going to return to the train scene because I think I can clean that up too before moving on to the next bit (final part of Act 1).
Rethinking how to start scene 2, saving time animating Fred and Doris walking across the window, the main bit of visual information in this shot is a) the church window (to establish they are at a church) and b) the evacuee poster to explicitly explain the situation, them walking across the window was mainly to establish they are inside but the next shot pretty much does that anyway and I don't want to distract from that important bit of information. After the window shot I was going to have the suitcase tags close up, I've also rejigged this. Instead when Doris's host approaches, they look at her tag only before getting her attention. When Fred goes to grab his things is when we see the close up of his tag.
Here's a sneak peak (screenshot only) at the next part I've begun re-animating. So this part is what comes after the hug and look up, Fred goes to pick up his bag "Where do you think you're going?" and stops. "Well he can't come with us, darlin' ", Doris at first taking the protectivestance 'where he goes, I go', she quickly realises she has no choice in the matter before being hurried on to leave.
I've been working on this shot for a while now in between set modelling, lighting and texturing. It's not quite there yet but I can see I've improved from my previous attempt. As my understanding of animating grows so does my understanding of what I'm trying to tell through it. So what I'm trying to tell in this shot, Fred is feeling anxious so he doesn't tend to look at his surroundings too much, rather he looks downward, he looks briefly to Doris questioningly. He is a 9 year old kid who doesn't understand anything that's going on, Doris is his only comfort and familiarity, he is dependent on her which I try and show through their hug where he hugs/holds onto her. Doris being 4 years older has a bit more of a clue what's going on and is being more observant of her surroundings. The sound in this shot above the crowd noise you can hear the odd person say "I'll have you for my daughter" "I'll take you for my son", Doris looks down and has a moment where she thinks and becomes disconcerted. The hug also shows how precious her little brother is to her, she doesn't want to part with him so holds him tighter.
So today I had been trying to refine and better my animation for this shot but as you can tell it don't look too good or very natural. So here's my notes for me to bear in mind when I remake this scene tomorrow.
Think of animating in 3 beats, so for Doris her 3 beats are 1) when she's apart from Fred empathising with him, 2) the moment she decides to put her arm round him and 3) when she actually is hugging him. Depending on these is where I put the weight of the pose to keep the character's balance. Fred's 3 beats are 1) looking around anxiously, 2) looking to Doris for comfort and 3) submitting to her nudge to hug. I start with these poses which I start sculpting from the middle of the character's body, when I have the body right the facial animation goes over that and I make the inbetween poses.
After talking to Alan and Phil yesterday about my animation in Scene 1, I spent today revisiting it, in addition to carrying over the lighting from Shot 1 to Shots 2 and 3. One of the things that needed work was the eye darting to make it more lifelike - I revisited the facial animation presentation from second year and attempted to do some more eye darting for my characters and changed the positioning of the eyes individually which I hadn't before. They also pointed out how my characters move quite slowly, to be honest I don't really know why I did it, I think it's to do with how my mind understands and mimics life, I slow it right down to process what's actually happening within a second that speeding it back to real time feels strange but also when I work with something for so long I lose any sense of judgement. My focus mainly was with Doris's timing - I think I might need to speed Fred up a bit, I can't really tell at the moment. Doris still needs some refinement, however I've cut out a bit of what was in the first version, they no longer look out the window together, instead Doris looks straight at Fred. Part of what I struggle with is getting inside the head of my characters, it would be easier if they were made up characters but I'm trying to think of who they actually were and what they had done. This version is missing the matte paintings and clouds as it's animation I've been focusing on and am showing in this post. I also decided to test the object wipe cut shot using an old playblast of Scene 2, Shot 1 - I think it works. Below the video is a render.
After yesterday I have a better understanding of lighting and what I'm trying to do with it. Before I was trying to get as close as I can to my finished shot in maya which in my case isn't what I should be trying to do. In maya I should be getting my tones right and using lighting to make my characters stand out from the background. The moodiness I want in this shot I can do in after effects with the use of blending modes, filters, desaturation etc. But also a render doesn't capture 100% of the tones, the little bit it doesn't I get back in post production. In the render view you can turn off luminosity and have it just show black and white which makes it easier to see where character tones blend in with background tones.
Untouched Render
To understand more of what I'm doing now I needed to have a better understanding of what I'm going to do later, so below Alan showed me in photoshop a few effects on a render of what I would perhaps do in After Effects and showed me how I'm going to get the light to show in the carriage from my matte painting, (gaussian blur on a layer above).
(This is just an example and not what my final shot will look like.)
Part 2 of backlog: over the weekend I animated, modelled,and textured Scene 2, Shot 1, during the week I have revisited and tried to improve it so its the best it can be, these frames rendered at about 6/7 minutes each.
I have labelled this post V1 because I plan to put my cloud renders over it (I've improvised with the planes for this version). I still have lighting to refine and to make work with the glass before this scene is completely done.
Here are all the glitches I have encountered today...